Click here to close now.

Welcome!

Java Authors: Carmen Gonzalez, Esmeralda Swartz, Jason Bloomberg, Greg O'Connor, Asad Ali

Related Topics: Java

Java: Article

Interfaces Vs Abstract Classes In Java

Interfaces Vs Abstract Classes In Java

Have you ever wondered why you should use interfaces instead of abstract classes, or vice versa? More specifically, when dealing with generalization, have you struggled with using one or the other? I'll shed some light on what can be a very confusing issue.

To start, I'll identify two pieces of the development puzzle: the behavior of an object and the object's implementation.

When designing an entity that can have more than one implementation, the goal is to describe the entity's behavior in such a way that it can be used without knowing exactly how the entity's behavior is implemented. In essence, you're separating the behavior of an object from its implementation. But is this separation best achieved by way of an interface or by way of an abstract class? Both can define methods without saying how they work. So which one do you use?

Modeling Behavior in an Abstract Class
As a rule, pure behavior is always modeled by interfaces and not in abstract classes. This example will model behavior in an abstract class to illustrate why.

Pretend you're designing a "motor" entity for an application that your sales department will use to sell motors. You're not modeling every aspect and nuance of a motor, but instead modeling what's important for the company and the process you're automating. (You find out what's important by talking to the users of a system. In this case it's your sales department. Good luck!)

Your sales department says that every motor has a horsepower rating, and this feature is the only attribute they're concerned with.

Based on this statement, you describe the following behavior of a motor:

Behavior: Someone can ask the motor for its horsepower rating, and the motor will return its rating as an integer.

At this point you don't know where the horsepower comes from, but you do know that this behavior must exist.

Translated into a method signature this behavior becomes:

public int getHorsepower()

Your company has several different types of motors, but given our particular application, this behavior is the only rule that applies to all of them. You look at both interfaces and abstract classes, but for purposes of illustration the motors will be modeled as an abstract class.

public abstract Motor{
abstract public int getHorsepower();
}
You make a handful of concrete implementations of this class, and version 1.0 of the application enters production.

Time passes and you're called to create version 2.0. While reviewing the requirements for the second version, you find that a small subset of motors is battery-powered, and that these batteries take time to recharge. The sales department wants to be able to view the time to recharge from the computer screen. From their statement, you derive a behavior:

Behavior: Someone can ask a battery-powered motor for its time to recharge and the motor will return its time as an integer.

public int getTimeToRecharge();
Translated into a method signature this behavior becomes:
public abstract BatteryPoweredMotor extends Motor{
abstract public int getTimeToRecharge();
}
The new battery-powered motors are implemented inside the application as concrete classes. It's important to note that these classes extend Battery- PoweredMotor as opposed to Motor. The changes are released as version 2 and the sales department is happy once again.

But business is changing, and soon solar-powered motors are introduced. The sales department tells you that solar-powered motors require a minimum amount of light energy to operate. This light energy is measured in lumens. The customers want to know this information. There's a fear that on cloudy days some solar-powered motors won't operate. The sales department requests that the application be changed to support the new solar-powered motors. From listening to their plight, a behavior is derived.

Behavior: Someone can ask a solar-powered battery for its lumens required to operate and the motor will return an integer.

public int getLumensToOperate();
In an Abstract class
public abstract SolarPoweredMotor extends Motor{
abstract public int getLumensToOperate();
}
Both SolarPoweredMotor and BatteryPoweredMotor extend the abstract class Motor (see Figure 1).

Throughout your application, motors are treated the same in 90% of the code. When you're checking if you have a solar- or battery-powered motor, use instanceof.

if (instanceof SolarPoweredMotor){...} if (instanceof BatteryPoweredMotor){...}
You find out that horsepower is calculated for each type of motor so the getHorsepower() method is overloaded in each of the derived abstract classes. So far, this design looks good...

That is, until you find out that the sales department wants to sell a new type of motor that has both battery and solar power! The behaviors associated with solar- and battery-powered motors haven't changed. The only difference is you have a handful of motors that exhibit both behaviors.

The Problem with Modeling Behavior in an Abstract Class
Here's where the difference between an interface and an abstract class becomes apparent.

The goal is to add these motors with as little rework as possible. After all, code related to battery- and solar-powered motors is well tested and has no known bugs.

You can make a new abstract class that's SolarBatteryPowered but then your motor won't trigger your instanceof when you check for solar- and battery-powered motors. The other option is to make the new motor extend either the SolarPowered or BatteryPowered abstract class. But if you do that, the new motor will lose the functionality of the abstract class it didn't extend. Technically your new motor needs to extend both abstract classes, but you painted yourself into a corner that can be solved only with a lot of special-case coding.

The reason you're having problems is that by using abstract classes you implied not only a behavior hierarchy but a pattern of implementation as well! You modeled how the motors receive their behavior instead of just saying the motors have a specific behavior.

While the phrase "Someone can ask the motor for its horsepower rating, and the motor will return the rating as an integer" implies something about the behavior of an object, it doesn't deny any behavior. Nevertheless, when you modeled with abstract classes, you created an implementation pattern that later was found to be incorrect, even though the behavior in the hierarchy was accurate.

Modeling Behavior in an Interface
You can avoid accidentally implying an implementation pattern if you model behavior using interfaces. Let's review the behavior:

Behavior: Someone can ask the motor for its horsepower rating, and the motor will return its rating as an integer.

public interface Motor(){
public int getHorsepower();
}
Behavior: Somone can ask a battery-powered motor for its time to recharge and the motor will return its time as an integer.
public interface BatteryPoweredMotor extends Motor(){
public int getTimeToRecharge();
}
Behavior: Somone can ask a solar-powered motor for its lumens required to operate, and the motor will return its lumens as an integer.
public interface SolarPoweredMotor extends Motor{
abstract public int getLumensToOperate();
}
In this way, only behavior is modeled (see Figure 2).

Now, I'll describe the solar-battery-powered motor in question:

public DualMotor implements SolarPoweredMotor, BatteryPoweredMotor{
}
The dual-powered motor inherits behavior, not implementation (see Figure 3).

You can use abstract classes just as before, except in this case the abstract classes implement behaviors instead of defining them (see Figure 4).

Notice the two separate hierarchies. The interface defines behavior in a very pure way while the abstract class defines a pattern for implementation - including the origin of a given behavior. Notice how the bottom half of the diagram can be totally redesigned and yet the behavioral hierarchy remains intact. As long as the implementing class relies on the interfaces for behavior, the implementing class can change its parent abstract class without changing how other pieces of the code interact with it.

When to Use Abstract Classes
Now that I've fully discussed interfaces, abstract classes may seem like an evil half brother - something to be avoided. This is not the case! When you have a common implementation, abstract classes shine. Using abstract classes you can enforce an implementation hierarchy and avoid duplicate code. Using abstract classes, however, should not affect your decision to use interfaces to define your behavior.

Both parent and child abstract classes should implement interfaces that define the expected behavior if you think the implementation will change. In practice, relying on abstract classes to define behavior leads to an inheritance nightmare, while coding behavior with interfaces provides a cleaner separation of behavior and implementation. Thus it makes your code more resistant to change. If you want to modify your existing code to improve your design, I recommend reading Martin Fowler's book, Refactoring: Improving the Design of Existing Code (Addison-Wesley, 1999). He devotes an entire chapter to refactorings dealing with generalization.

More Stories By Anthony Meyer

Anthony Meyer is a
technical director and a Java developer at Flashline.com. His
experience includes the design, development and implementation of
large-scale, Java-based, Internet applications in the corporate Web
development environment. He has also created and implemented
corporate-focused reuse strategies in the
financial industry.

Comments (0)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


@ThingsExpo Stories
Wearable technology was dominant at this year’s International Consumer Electronics Show (CES) , and MWC was no exception to this trend. New versions of favorites, such as the Samsung Gear (three new products were released: the Gear 2, the Gear 2 Neo and the Gear Fit), shared the limelight with new wearables like Pebble Time Steel (the new premium version of the company’s previously released smartwatch) and the LG Watch Urbane. The most dramatic difference at MWC was an emphasis on presenting wearables as fashion accessories and moving away from the original clunky technology associated with t...
After making a doctor’s appointment via your mobile device, you receive a calendar invite. The day of your appointment, you get a reminder with the doctor’s location and contact information. As you enter the doctor’s exam room, the medical team is equipped with the latest tablet containing your medical history – he or she makes real time updates to your medical file. At the end of your visit, you receive an electronic prescription to your preferred pharmacy and can schedule your next appointment.
Containers and microservices have become topics of intense interest throughout the cloud developer and enterprise IT communities. Accordingly, attendees at the upcoming 16th Cloud Expo at the Javits Center in New York June 9-11 will find fresh new content in a new track called PaaS | Containers & Microservices Containers are not being considered for the first time by the cloud community, but a current era of re-consideration has pushed them to the top of the cloud agenda. With the launch of Docker's initial release in March of 2013, interest was revved up several notches. Then late last...
The WebRTC Summit 2014 New York, to be held June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York, NY, announces that its Call for Papers is open. Topics include all aspects of improving IT delivery by eliminating waste through automated business models leveraging cloud technologies. WebRTC Summit is co-located with 16th International Cloud Expo, @ThingsExpo, Big Data Expo, and DevOps Summit.
SOA Software has changed its name to Akana. With roots in Web Services and SOA Governance, Akana has established itself as a leader in API Management and is expanding into cloud integration as an alternative to the traditional heavyweight enterprise service bus (ESB). The company recently announced that it achieved more than 90% year-over-year growth. As Akana, the company now addresses the evolution and diversification of SOA, unifying security, management, and DevOps across SOA, APIs, microservices, and more.
GENBAND has announced that SageNet is leveraging the Nuvia platform to deliver Unified Communications as a Service (UCaaS) to its large base of retail and enterprise customers. Nuvia’s cloud-based solution provides SageNet’s customers with a full suite of business communications and collaboration tools. Two large national SageNet retail customers have recently signed up to deploy the Nuvia platform and the company will continue to sell the service to new and existing customers. Nuvia’s capabilities include HD voice, video, multimedia messaging, mobility, conferencing, Web collaboration, deskt...
SYS-CON Media announced today that @WebRTCSummit Blog, the largest WebRTC resource in the world, has been launched. @WebRTCSummit Blog offers top articles, news stories, and blog posts from the world's well-known experts and guarantees better exposure for its authors than any other publication. @WebRTCSummit Blog can be bookmarked ▸ Here @WebRTCSummit conference site can be bookmarked ▸ Here
SYS-CON Events announced today that Cisco, the worldwide leader in IT that transforms how people connect, communicate and collaborate, has been named “Gold Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 16th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Cisco makes amazing things happen by connecting the unconnected. Cisco has shaped the future of the Internet by becoming the worldwide leader in transforming how people connect, communicate and collaborate. Cisco and our partners are building the platform for the Internet of Everything by connecting the...
SYS-CON Events announced today that robomq.io will exhibit at SYS-CON's @ThingsExpo, which will take place on June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. robomq.io is an interoperable and composable platform that connects any device to any application. It helps systems integrators and the solution providers build new and innovative products and service for industries requiring monitoring or intelligence from devices and sensors.
Temasys has announced senior management additions to its team. Joining are David Holloway as Vice President of Commercial and Nadine Yap as Vice President of Product. Over the past 12 months Temasys has doubled in size as it adds new customers and expands the development of its Skylink platform. Skylink leads the charge to move WebRTC, traditionally seen as a desktop, browser based technology, to become a ubiquitous web communications technology on web and mobile, as well as Internet of Things compatible devices.
Docker is an excellent platform for organizations interested in running microservices. It offers portability and consistency between development and production environments, quick provisioning times, and a simple way to isolate services. In his session at DevOps Summit at 16th Cloud Expo, Shannon Williams, co-founder of Rancher Labs, will walk through these and other benefits of using Docker to run microservices, and provide an overview of RancherOS, a minimalist distribution of Linux designed expressly to run Docker. He will also discuss Rancher, an orchestration and service discovery platf...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Vitria Technology, Inc. will exhibit at SYS-CON’s @ThingsExpo, which will take place on June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Vitria will showcase the company’s new IoT Analytics Platform through live demonstrations at booth #330. Vitria’s IoT Analytics Platform, fully integrated and powered by an operational intelligence engine, enables customers to rapidly build and operationalize advanced analytics to deliver timely business outcomes for use cases across the industrial, enterprise, and consumer segments.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Solgenia will exhibit at SYS-CON's 16th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY, and the 17th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on November 3–5, 2015, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. Solgenia is the global market leader in Cloud Collaboration and Cloud Infrastructure software solutions. Designed to “Bridge the Gap” between Personal and Professional Social, Mobile and Cloud user experiences, our solutions help large and medium-sized organizations dr...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Liaison Technologies, a leading provider of data management and integration cloud services and solutions, has been named "Silver Sponsor" of SYS-CON's 16th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York, NY. Liaison Technologies is a recognized market leader in providing cloud-enabled data integration and data management solutions to break down complex information barriers, enabling enterprises to make smarter decisions, faster.
@ThingsExpo has been named the Top 5 Most Influential M2M Brand by Onalytica in the ‘Machine to Machine: Top 100 Influencers and Brands.' Onalytica analyzed the online debate on M2M by looking at over 85,000 tweets to provide the most influential individuals and brands that drive the discussion. According to Onalytica the "analysis showed a very engaged community with a lot of interactive tweets. The M2M discussion seems to be more fragmented and driven by some of the major brands present in the M2M space. This really allows some room for influential individuals to create more high value inter...
The world's leading Cloud event, Cloud Expo has launched Microservices Journal on the SYS-CON.com portal, featuring over 19,000 original articles, news stories, features, and blog entries. DevOps Journal is focused on this critical enterprise IT topic in the world of cloud computing. Microservices Journal offers top articles, news stories, and blog posts from the world's well-known experts and guarantees better exposure for its authors than any other publication. Follow new article posts on Twitter at @MicroservicesE
The list of ‘new paradigm’ technologies that now surrounds us appears to be at an all time high. From cloud computing and Big Data analytics to Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) and the Internet of Things (IoT), today we have to deal with what the industry likes to call ‘paradigm shifts’ at every level of IT. This is disruption; of course, we understand that – change is almost always disruptive.
SYS-CON Events announced today the IoT Bootcamp – Jumpstart Your IoT Strategy, being held June 9–10, 2015, in conjunction with 16th Cloud Expo and Internet of @ThingsExpo at the Javits Center in New York City. This is your chance to jumpstart your IoT strategy. Combined with real-world scenarios and use cases, the IoT Bootcamp is not just based on presentations but includes hands-on demos and walkthroughs. We will introduce you to a variety of Do-It-Yourself IoT platforms including Arduino, Raspberry Pi, BeagleBone, Spark and Intel Edison. You will also get an overview of cloud technologies s...
SYS-CON Events announced today that SafeLogic has been named “Bag Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 16th International Cloud Expo® New York, which will take place June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. SafeLogic provides security products for applications in mobile and server/appliance environments. SafeLogic’s flagship product CryptoComply is a FIPS 140-2 validated cryptographic engine designed to secure data on servers, workstations, appliances, mobile devices, and in the Cloud.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Akana, formerly SOA Software, has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 16th International Cloud Expo® New York, which will take place June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Akana’s comprehensive suite of API Management, API Security, Integrated SOA Governance, and Cloud Integration solutions helps businesses accelerate digital transformation by securely extending their reach across multiple channels – mobile, cloud and Internet of Things. Akana enables enterprises to share data as APIs, connect and integrate applications, drive part...