Welcome!

Java Authors: App Man, Liz McMillan, Jeremy Geelan, Yakov Fain, Hari Gottipati

Related Topics: Linux, Open Source

Linux: Article

"Linux Games Drive Linux Desktop Growth," Says LeBlanc

The selection of RSS as "Best Game" for the Linux Journal's Editor's Choice Awards is "harmful to the Linux desktop community,"

[An open letter to the Linux Journal from the Gaming Industry Editor of LinuxWorld Magazine]

Dear Linux Journal Editors,

This is not sour grapes from a competitor. Far from it, our publications serve different segments of the Linux audience and in general are more complementary than competition.

However, while at LinuxWorld Expo in San Francisco I was disappointed to hear that when announcing your Editor's Choice Awards for 2004, here is what you have for the games category:

Game: Really Simple Syndication (RSS)

Our editors are all business and turned up their noses at selecting favorite games. These are the kind of people you want to hire to roll out your company desktop systems. But even though it might not look like Quake or Frozen Bubble when the boss walks by, there's a new hit game that Linux people are playing on the Net, and whether you want to call it blogging or social software, players are everywhere. It's like painting Dungeons and Dragons figures or collecting baseball cards, but with real people.

The glue tying it all together is a simple XML-based syndication format called RSS, which sites such as Technorati and software projects such as Planet are using to bring together Web content in new ways. Who's a blog king and who's a bozo? Pop in to Technorati to check the score.

Reuven points out that the all-in-one social network sites LinkedIn, Orkut and Ryze aren't particularly useful, but he says they're"all scratching the surface of something new and interesting." It gets really interesting when social networking info crosses site boundaries and anyone can crawl it. Game on!

I'm sure you folks thought you were being cute, I've met Don Marti and Doc Searls at multiple events and have always enjoyed talking to them. However, this selection is in fact harmful to the Linux desktop community.

Trying to get major game publishers take Linux gamers seriously is a difficult task, and when publications that much of the Linux community reads such as yours basically blow games off and give a game award to a non-game, you make the task far more arduous.

I mean, come on, what about Unreal Tournament 2004? What about the open source FreeCiv or Wesnoth? Heck, even picking Mahjongg or Solitaire (and I'm not knocking those, I probably play them more than the others) would have been healthier for our community than blowing off games like they just don't matter.

Games drive desktop growth, both in the number of users who move over, and for desktop technology in general.

I urge you to reconsider this policy when it comes time to look at your Editor's Choice Awards again in 2005. If you really don't want to look at games, then why have a category for them at all? If you wanted to give RSS an award, then create a suitable category for it. Don't hurt the desktop community just because your editorial staff apparently has no free time! (Tongue firmly in cheek, here.)

Sincerely,

Dee-Ann LeBlanc
Gaming Industry Editor
LinuxWorld Magazine

More Stories By Dee-Ann LeBlanc

Dee-Ann LeBlanc has been involved with Linux since 1994. She is the author of 12 books, 130 articles, and has more of both coming. She is a trainer, a course developer - including the official Red Hat online courseware at DigitalThink - a founding member of the AnswerSquad, and a consultant.

Comments (11) View Comments

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


Most Recent Comments
Robert Reed 08/26/04 05:06:28 PM EDT

Bryan Lee:

PC gaming being a joke is a matter of opinion. I like some computer games, and am developing two console-style games for the computer. Anyways, the PC gaming market is still very large, and continues to grow. Companies continue to turn out major hits. If these games (such as Doom 3 and Half Life 2) are not available for Linux, that will turn away a lot of possible linux converts.

And as for another great game on Linux, I am shocked that no one mentioned Enemy Territory. In fact, I like it even better than UT2004.

New Linux Gamer 08/26/04 03:55:07 PM EDT

I agree completely with these comments. The only reason my husband was able to finally dual-boot Linux on my laptop was so I could play LBreakout. He's a newly converted Linux user (after 10 years as a all-Microsoft, all the time). Now I'm slowly checking out other pieces of Linux, and albeit slowly, checking out other features and apps on Linux. Very soon our house will be all Linux. The easiest way to show the "coolness" of a system to a casual user is to show them the Linux games.

Solitaire is an integral part of Windows because it's the greatest way to learn how to use the mouse. Games play an integral part in an operating system - don't forget that LJ!

Sean Sullivan 08/17/04 10:32:18 PM EDT

I totally agree. I am not even a gamer personally. Around once a month I play 20 mins of UT2004 or America's Army only to remember how fast a PC I built. If these games didn't run on Linux, I wouldn't play them at all. All Linux in my house, All the time.

However, the reason the parts are even available for me to build a superfast box is due to the gaming community. They are the ones that shell out $500 for the newest vid card, or $700 for the latest CPU. They completely drive the hardware market. Since all the games are released for the Windows OS, thats all they are worried about creating drivers for. I can't even buy the latest and greatist if I wanted to because none of it will work on my Gentoo box.

I know at least 20 people that are interested enough in Linux that they would try it if they could play their games in it. We need that support. I have to admit though, I still make out on hardware thanks to the gamers. All I have to do is by the 2nd oldest anything and I get it for half the price as when it came out. Thanks guys :~)

Byran Lee 08/17/04 01:27:01 PM EDT

Get real people. *ANY* sort of Gaming on the PC is a *JOKE* these days.

The VAST Majority of Linux users *ARE NOT* PC Gamers. They own and buy games for the Playstation 2. We're pretty much aren't interested in the PC Gaming market.

PC Gaming is as much a joke as it is an endangered species and the guys at LJ know it.

Federico Kereki 08/17/04 10:21:59 AM EDT

This is completely moronic, and disrespectful both to RSS and to Linux game developers. Classifying RSS as a game is only possible if you don't know anything, either about games or about RSS.

I also run Windows just to be able to play some games, and agree that more games in Linux would mean more acceptance for its desktop.

Maybe it was done as a joke, but a extremely stupid one at that. They should apologize and consider staying away from such judgments in the future.

Sarah 08/17/04 01:02:41 AM EDT

I'm affraid I need to agree with everyone so far. The growth of the PC (and with it MS Software) for the home has always been driven by games. Be it Flight Sim or Doom they have brought computers to where they are.
To write off all of the open source games (FrozenBubble, TuxRacer, et al) and the closed source (Unreal Tournament 2003/2004, Neverwinter Nights, etc) is really a bit silly.
Ok perhaps you did just want to be a bit silly or cute but I'm affraid it's backfired.
As stupid as it sounds, Games are something a lot of people take quite seriously.

Bob Ossler 08/16/04 10:51:16 PM EDT

I agree 100%. I used to subscribe to LJ, but I've been disappointed in their content for almost a year now. This is just another slap in the face to a community dedicated to providing an alternative to Windows. I play games when I can find the time. I think Unreal Tournament 2003 and UT2004 are fantastic. Even my PS2 biased, teenage son prefers to play UT2004 than any other game. I also play America's Army on-line with the Linux client and have never had a problem. All the Windows users complain of critical errors, (maybe more hardware related??) but it has never crashed for me.

What about Eric's Ultimate Solitare?
How about Tux Racer?
Myth II?

The list goes on. LJ editors really missed an opportunity and I hope the rest of the community doesn't have to pay for it.

Jeff Smith 08/16/04 10:18:17 PM EDT

This is insulting both to Linux games (as has already been discussed) and to RSS (they speak of it as if it were merely a toy, much as Linux itself was once perceived).

John Helms 08/16/04 07:49:19 PM EDT

I totally agree. What kind of idiot made that decision???? How about Legends or UT2004, Cube, LBreakout, or any number of great games for Linux. Talk about Enderle and Didiot being clueless!!!!

Dennis Krøger 08/16/04 05:06:51 PM EDT

Agreed! Games and some engineering programs is all that keep me from full-time Desktop Linux, and peeing all over the game developers that DO try to make Linux games only makes matters worse...

Thom Paine 08/16/04 02:31:21 PM EDT

I wholeheartedly agree. That was nothing more than a slap in the face. The only reason I have Windows XP installed on my major desktop system is just so I can play StarWars Galaxies on it. I game alot, and wish the dev's would step up to the plate ang give me a version I can play on Linux. SWG is even run on Linux servers, so it's can't be that hard to make it work.

Anyhoo, back to work before I reboot and load up another game.