Welcome!

Java Authors: Trevor Parsons, Carmen Gonzalez, Peter Silva, Elizabeth White, Rex Morrow, Datical

Related Topics: Java

Java: Article

Java Gotchas: Instance Variables Hiding

Java Gotchas: Instance Variables Hiding

If methods with the same signatures or member variables with the same name exist in ancestor and descendant classes, the Java keyword super allows access members of the ancestor. But what if you do not use the keyword super in the descendant class? In case of methods, this is called method overriding and only the code of the descendant's method will execute. But when both classes have a member variable with the same name, it may cause a confusion and create hard to find bugs.

Recently in one of the Java online forums, a user with id cityart posted a question about a "strange behavior" of his program, and I decided to do some research on this subject.

Let's take a look at the Java program that declares a variable greeting in both super and subclasses (class A and class B). The subclass B also overrides the Object's method toString(). Please note, that the variable obj has a type of the superclass (A), but it points at the instance of the subclass (B), which is perfectly legal.


class A {
   public String greeting ="Hello";
}

class B extends A {
	public String greeting="Good Bye";
	 public String toString(){
		return greeting;
	}
}

public class VariableOverridingTest {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
      A obj = new B();
      obj.greeting="How are you";

      System.out.println(obj.greeting);
      System.out.println(obj.toString());
 }
}

If you compile and run this program, it'll print the following:

How are you
Good Bye

How come? Aren't we printing a member variable greeting of the same instance of the class B? The answer is no. If you run this program in IDE through a debugger, you'll see that there are two separate variables greeting. For example, Eclipse IDE shows these variables as greeting(A) and greeting(B). The first print statement deals with the member variable of the class A since obj has a type A, and the second print uses a method of the instance B that uses its own variable greeting.

Now, change the declaration of the variable obj to


      B obj = new B();

Run the program, and it'll print "How are you" twice.

But since you wanted the variable obj to have the type of the superclass A, you need to find a different solution. In the code below, we prohibit direct access to the variable greeting by making it private and introducing public setter and getter methods in both super and subclasses. Please note that in the following example, we override the setter and getter in the class B. This gives us a better control of which variable greeting to use.


class A {
 private String greeting ="Hello";
 public void setGreeting(String greet){greeting = greet;}
 public String getGreeting(){return greeting;}

}

class B extends A {
	 private String greeting="Good Bye";
	 public String toString(){
		return greeting;
	}
public void setGreeting(String greet){greeting = greet;}
public String getGreeting(){return greeting;}

}

public class VariableOverridingTest2 {
public static void main(String[] args) {
A obj = new B();

obj.setGreeting("How are you");

System.out.println(obj.getGreeting());
System.out.println(obj.toString());

}
}

This example is yet another illustration of how encapsulation may help you to avoid potential errors caused by multiple declarations of member variables with the same name in the inheritance hierarchy. If needed, we still can access the superclass' variable greeting from the class B by using super.getGreeting().

In Sun's Java tutorial, I found only a brief mentioning of member variables inheritance over here: http://java.sun.com/docs/books/tutorial/java/javaOO/subclass.html

Basically, you can hide a variable but override a method of a superclass. Java Language Specification describes hiding of instance variables over here: http://java.sun.com/docs/books/jls/ second_edition/html/classes.doc.html#229119

One more term to be aware of is shadowing. Here's another Sun's article that discusses hiding and shadowing: http://java.sun.com/developer/TechTips/2000/tt1010.html#tip2 What do you think of the following quote from this article: "First an important point needs to be made: just because the Java programming language allows you to do something, it doesn't always mean that it's a desirable thing to do." Well, if a feature is not desirable, why keep it in the language? Most likely, creators of the language decided to keep a separate copy of the superclass' instance variable to give developers a freedom to define their own subclasses without worrying of overriding by accident some internal members of the superclasses. But in my opinion it should be a responsibility of the superclasses to protect their members.

I'd love to see some practical examples, which would show when this feature of the Java language could be useful.

More Stories By Yakov Fain

Yakov Fain is a co-founder of two software companies: Farata Systems and SuranceBay. He authored several technical books and lots of articles on software development. Yakov is Java Champion (https://java-champions.java.net). He leads leads Princeton Java Users Group. Two of Yakov's books will go in print this year: "Enterprise Web Development" (O'Reilly) and "Java For Kids" (No Starch Press).

Comments (11) View Comments

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


Most Recent Comments
Chakra Yadavalli 09/15/04 08:53:53 AM EDT

I guess the author clearly states what the problem is and how the encapsulation helps in avoiding the potential errors. I think the following line from the text of the article would be enough to red flag this for any rational developer. Or, this may make it more noticeable :-)

LOOK AT THE LINE BELOW. POTENTIAL BUG!!!

"This example is yet another illustration of how encapsulation may help you to avoid potential errors caused by multiple declarations of member variables with the same name in the inheritance hierarchy. If needed, we still can access the superclass' variable greeting from the class B by using super.getGreeting()."

And in most scenarios of real software development, we never have the luxury of time to track the "patient zero" who coded this sort of bug and treat him. :-)

As for the existence of debates such as this, THEY SHOULD (I mean MUST) exist for the sake of posterity. The correct solutions to these problems to be aware of such problems. If one thinks that articles such as this are "encouraging" the such "malpractices" (without reading the complete articles) then they are wrong and should be advised to use good commonsense in adopting coding techniques.

F. Libuste 09/15/04 07:53:37 AM EDT

The problem of hiding variables will never arise if you apply good practices of Oriented Object programming and NEVER make use of anything else than "private" as a modifier for class members. And yse accessors when needed.

Now as for method overriding, well...that is *exactly* what OO design is for. Making sure your objects are correctly polymorphic, behave properly and offer the proper services and proper extensibility through their exposed methods.

This whole debate should not exist in the first place, and to me, the article comes from software malpractice, and is not depicted as such, which is not so good IMHO. Correct OO design is the issue that should be addressed here, not the effects of it.

Chakra Yadavalli 09/14/04 11:07:46 AM EDT

Good pitfall. This is quite common and very had to find if you have more than two classes in the inheritance tree and the instance members are "protected" which is very common thing that we see. If we go by Bertrand Myer's Object Oriented software construction, which enforces strict encapsulation by saying no to protected variables, we will *not* run in to these sort of problems. But then again, we may be tempted to write "Train Wreck" code -- obj.getThis().getThat().getSomething()

There is another pitfall that has the disguise of this "overridding." Guess what is printed by the following code?

public class A {
public static void getInstance(){
System.out.println("class A");
}
}

public class B extends A {
public static void getInstance(){
System.out.println("class B");
}
}

public class Tester {
public staic void main(Strnig[] args) {
A obj = new B();
obj.getInstance();
}
}

This would print "class A" because, the static methods go by the name "class methods" in Java. In C++, similar code would print "class B". Java language says, static/class methods are not inherited and cannot be overriden. But allowing to define classes with the same name, though legal when looked from the namespace perspective, would result in these pitfalls. The irony with these "false" static methods AKA class methods is that, it makes your brain hurt when you look at code like the one below... Keeps you guessing why it does not throw NullPointerException.

A obj = null;
obj.getInstance();

These are the many good reasons why one should enforce, with the help of IDEs like Eclipse, the practice of qualifying instance members with "this", "super" and static members with the "type name".

Sebastian Tyrrell 09/14/04 10:39:38 AM EDT

Both David Hibbs and J.R. Titko are right that there is no problem if the design is right - in particular if you have proper encapsulation (i.e. keep the data member private and use getter and setter functions). But I still can't imagine a single legitimate usage. The closest I can come is that it means that you don't need to worry what (private) data members base classes might have, and can reuse their names for your own purposes. I think this is what David means when he says "... the capability to do this is required or else behaviours of parent classes are not encapsulated ...". I'm not convinced - a compile error at this point might save a lot of grief later.

David Hibbs 09/14/04 09:30:26 AM EDT

Mr. Tyrrell commented that "...it is the type of the object, not the type of the pointer, that determines the behaviour. To me, that makes it a fault rather than a feature!"

In some regards, yes. The key word here though is "behaviour". Behaviour as in, what happens when a method is invoked? Direct access of fields (IMHO) is not a "behaviour" of an object.

Allowing access to member fields like this is poor style and design in any OO language.

Proper encapsulation helps this problem. This is not to say that encapsulation is a cure-all; indeed, generating getters and setters for the field in the child class (in effect, overriding them and shadowing them at the same time!) can create a whole new set of hard-to-find bugs.

The bottom line: proper design, planning, and review will avoid the pitfall, while the capability to do this is required or else behaviors of parent classes are not encapsulated -- and subject to breakage by children.

J.R. Titko 09/14/04 09:27:52 AM EDT

I have been using this example when teaching for a couple years to show what to avoid in coding Java. It is a situation set up at compile time by the compiler making the substitution of the literal for the variable. I agree its a problem in the language, but can easily be avoided by always using getters and setters to revtrieve instance level variables.

Sebastián Tyrrell 09/14/04 08:10:42 AM EDT

It seems to me from the examples that there is no way of utilising this feature without breaking the Liskov substitution principle that it is the type of the object, not the type of the pointer, that determines the behaviour. To me, that makes it a fault rather than a feature!

Sudipto Nandan 09/14/04 06:41:38 AM EDT

The article is good but can be very briefly eneded by saying that
When a method is called by a reference object, it takes into consideration the Object it is referencing and not the type of referencing object.
While, when a memeber variable is accessed by a reference object, the type of the referencing object is taken into consideration and not the object it is referencing.

MarkusH 09/14/04 05:13:39 AM EDT

This is another example how important it is, that every Developer has easy to use access to Software Audits in it's IDE, so that suspicious constructs like this don't survive until the check-in... i.e. the Audits provided by Borland Together in JBuilder and Eclipse-based IDE's

Narayanan R 09/14/04 12:43:11 AM EDT

It was interesting. It is the behavior of an object that is defined by its type (whose instance it is). I think the attributes of an object are defined by the handle used, since in Java methods are only bound at runtime.
Simple typecasting with the superclass/subclass can have obtained the desired result, as long as the typecast is valid.

Just Nell 09/13/04 09:53:13 PM EDT

Perhaps a better way to demonstrate is to print obj.greeting before setting, e.g.,

A obj = new B();
System.out.println(obj.greeting);
obj.greeting="How are you";

System.out.println(obj.greeting);
System.out.println(obj.toString());

@ThingsExpo Stories
Software AG helps organizations transform into Digital Enterprises, so they can differentiate from competitors and better engage customers, partners and employees. Using the Software AG Suite, companies can close the gap between business and IT to create digital systems of differentiation that drive front-line agility. We offer four on-ramps to the Digital Enterprise: alignment through collaborative process analysis; transformation through portfolio management; agility through process automation and integration; and visibility through intelligent business operations and big data.
There will be 50 billion Internet connected devices by 2020. Today, every manufacturer has a propriety protocol and an app. How do we securely integrate these "things" into our lives and businesses in a way that we can easily control and manage? Even better, how do we integrate these "things" so that they control and manage each other so our lives become more convenient or our businesses become more profitable and/or safe? We have heard that the best interface is no interface. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Chris Matthieu, Co-Founder & CTO at Octoblu, Inc., will discuss how these devices generate enough data to learn our behaviors and simplify/improve our lives. What if we could connect everything to everything? I'm not only talking about connecting things to things but also systems, cloud services, and people. Add in a little machine learning and artificial intelligence and now we have something interesting...
Last week, while in San Francisco, I used the Uber app and service four times. All four experiences were great, although one of the drivers stopped for 30 seconds and then left as I was walking up to the car. He must have realized I was a blogger. None the less, the next car was just a minute away and I suffered no pain. In this article, my colleague, Ved Sen, Global Head, Advisory Services Social, Mobile and Sensors at Cognizant shares his experiences and insights.
We are reaching the end of the beginning with WebRTC and real systems using this technology have begun to appear. One challenge that faces every WebRTC deployment (in some form or another) is identity management. For example, if you have an existing service – possibly built on a variety of different PaaS/SaaS offerings – and you want to add real-time communications you are faced with a challenge relating to user management, authentication, authorization, and validation. Service providers will want to use their existing identities, but these will have credentials already that are (hopefully) irreversibly encoded. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Peter Dunkley, Technical Director at Acision, will look at how this identity problem can be solved and discuss ways to use existing web identities for real-time communication.
Can call centers hang up the phones for good? Intuitive Solutions did. WebRTC enabled this contact center provider to eliminate antiquated telephony and desktop phone infrastructure with a pure web-based solution, allowing them to expand beyond brick-and-mortar confines to a home-based agent model. It also ensured scalability and better service for customers, including MUY! Companies, one of the country's largest franchise restaurant companies with 232 Pizza Hut locations. This is one example of WebRTC adoption today, but the potential is limitless when powered by IoT. Attendees will learn real-world benefits of WebRTC and explore future possibilities, as WebRTC and IoT intersect to improve customer service.
From telemedicine to smart cars, digital homes and industrial monitoring, the explosive growth of IoT has created exciting new business opportunities for real time calls and messaging. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Ivelin Ivanov, CEO and Co-Founder of Telestax, will share some of the new revenue sources that IoT created for Restcomm – the open source telephony platform from Telestax. Ivelin Ivanov is a technology entrepreneur who founded Mobicents, an Open Source VoIP Platform, to help create, deploy, and manage applications integrating voice, video and data. He is the co-founder of TeleStax, an Open Source Cloud Communications company that helps the shift from legacy IN/SS7 telco networks to IP-based cloud comms. An early investor in multiple start-ups, he still finds time to code for his companies and contribute to open source projects.
The Internet of Things (IoT) promises to create new business models as significant as those that were inspired by the Internet and the smartphone 20 and 10 years ago. What business, social and practical implications will this phenomenon bring? That's the subject of "Monetizing the Internet of Things: Perspectives from the Front Lines," an e-book released today and available free of charge from Aria Systems, the leading innovator in recurring revenue management.
The Internet of Things will put IT to its ultimate test by creating infinite new opportunities to digitize products and services, generate and analyze new data to improve customer satisfaction, and discover new ways to gain a competitive advantage across nearly every industry. In order to help corporate business units to capitalize on the rapidly evolving IoT opportunities, IT must stand up to a new set of challenges.
There’s Big Data, then there’s really Big Data from the Internet of Things. IoT is evolving to include many data possibilities like new types of event, log and network data. The volumes are enormous, generating tens of billions of logs per day, which raise data challenges. Early IoT deployments are relying heavily on both the cloud and managed service providers to navigate these challenges. In her session at 6th Big Data Expo®, Hannah Smalltree, Director at Treasure Data, to discuss how IoT, Big Data and deployments are processing massive data volumes from wearables, utilities and other machines.
All major researchers estimate there will be tens of billions devices – computers, smartphones, tablets, and sensors – connected to the Internet by 2020. This number will continue to grow at a rapid pace for the next several decades. With major technology companies and startups seriously embracing IoT strategies, now is the perfect time to attend @ThingsExpo in Silicon Valley. Learn what is going on, contribute to the discussions, and ensure that your enterprise is as "IoT-Ready" as it can be!
P2P RTC will impact the landscape of communications, shifting from traditional telephony style communications models to OTT (Over-The-Top) cloud assisted & PaaS (Platform as a Service) communication services. The P2P shift will impact many areas of our lives, from mobile communication, human interactive web services, RTC and telephony infrastructure, user federation, security and privacy implications, business costs, and scalability. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Erik Lagerway, Co-founder of Hookflash, will walk through the shifting landscape of traditional telephone and voice services to the modern P2P RTC era of OTT cloud assisted services.
While great strides have been made relative to the video aspects of remote collaboration, audio technology has basically stagnated. Typically all audio is mixed to a single monaural stream and emanates from a single point, such as a speakerphone or a speaker associated with a video monitor. This leads to confusion and lack of understanding among participants especially regarding who is actually speaking. Spatial teleconferencing introduces the concept of acoustic spatial separation between conference participants in three dimensional space. This has been shown to significantly improve comprehension and conference efficiency.
The Internet of Things is tied together with a thin strand that is known as time. Coincidentally, at the core of nearly all data analytics is a timestamp. When working with time series data there are a few core principles that everyone should consider, especially across datasets where time is the common boundary. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Jim Scott, Director of Enterprise Strategy & Architecture at MapR Technologies, will discuss single-value, geo-spatial, and log time series data. By focusing on enterprise applications and the data center, he will use OpenTSDB as an example to explain some of these concepts including when to use different storage models.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Gridstore™, the leader in software-defined storage (SDS) purpose-built for Windows Servers and Hyper-V, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 15th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on November 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. Gridstore™ is the leader in software-defined storage purpose built for virtualization that is designed to accelerate applications in virtualized environments. Using its patented Server-Side Virtual Controller™ Technology (SVCT) to eliminate the I/O blender effect and accelerate applications Gridstore delivers vmOptimized™ Storage that self-optimizes to each application or VM across both virtual and physical environments. Leveraging a grid architecture, Gridstore delivers the first end-to-end storage QoS to ensure the most important App or VM performance is never compromised. The storage grid, that uses Gridstore’s performance optimized nodes or capacity optimized nodes, starts with as few a...
The Transparent Cloud-computing Consortium (abbreviation: T-Cloud Consortium) will conduct research activities into changes in the computing model as a result of collaboration between "device" and "cloud" and the creation of new value and markets through organic data processing High speed and high quality networks, and dramatic improvements in computer processing capabilities, have greatly changed the nature of applications and made the storing and processing of data on the network commonplace. These technological reforms have not only changed computers and smartphones, but are also changing the data processing model for all information devices. In particular, in the area known as M2M (Machine-To-Machine), there are great expectations that information with a new type of value can be produced using a variety of devices and sensors saving/sharing data via the network and through large-scale cloud-type data processing. This consortium believes that attaching a huge number of devic...
Innodisk is a service-driven provider of industrial embedded flash and DRAM storage products and technologies, with a focus on the enterprise, industrial, aerospace, and defense industries. Innodisk is dedicated to serving their customers and business partners. Quality is vitally important when it comes to industrial embedded flash and DRAM storage products. That’s why Innodisk manufactures all of their products in their own purpose-built memory production facility. In fact, they designed and built their production center to maximize manufacturing efficiency and guarantee the highest quality of our products.
All major researchers estimate there will be tens of billions devices - computers, smartphones, tablets, and sensors - connected to the Internet by 2020. This number will continue to grow at a rapid pace for the next several decades. Over the summer Gartner released its much anticipated annual Hype Cycle report and the big news is that Internet of Things has now replaced Big Data as the most hyped technology. Indeed, we're hearing more and more about this fascinating new technological paradigm. Every other IT news item seems to be about IoT and its implications on the future of digital business.
Can call centers hang up the phones for good? Intuitive Solutions did. WebRTC enabled this contact center provider to eliminate antiquated telephony and desktop phone infrastructure with a pure web-based solution, allowing them to expand beyond brick-and-mortar confines to a home-based agent model. Download Slide Deck: ▸ Here
BSQUARE is a global leader of embedded software solutions. We enable smart connected systems at the device level and beyond that millions use every day and provide actionable data solutions for the growing Internet of Things (IoT) market. We empower our world-class customers with our products, services and solutions to achieve innovation and success. For more information, visit www.bsquare.com.
With the iCloud scandal seemingly in its past, Apple announced new iPhones, updates to iPad and MacBook as well as news on OSX Yosemite. Although consumers will have to wait to get their hands on some of that new stuff, what they can get is the latest release of iOS 8 that Apple made available for most in-market iPhones and iPads. Originally announced at WWDC (Apple’s annual developers conference) in June, iOS 8 seems to spearhead Apple’s newfound focus upon greater integration of their products into everyday tasks, cross-platform mobility and self-monitoring. Before you update your device, here is a look at some of the new features and things you may want to consider from a mobile security perspective.