Welcome!

Java Authors: Michael Sheehan, Maureen O'Gara, Jonny Defh, Suresh Krishna Madhuvarsu, RealWire News Distribution

Related Topics: AJAX & REA

AJAX & REA: Article

Google Sites Launches, Using AJAX to Include Gadgets, to Mixed Reviews

"Spoiled by usability issues," says one industry blogger; "half-hearted" says another

Trumpeting it as the filling of “a key last hole in the Google Apps suite,” Matt Glotzbach, product management director for Google Enterprise, heralded the arrival of Google Sites - exclusively available in Google Apps - but early reactions have included industry bloggers who are not overly impressed with Google's use of AJAX despite its claim to make "Building a site...as simple as editing a document, and you don't need anyone's help to get started."

"Use Google Sites to centralize all types of information -- from videos to presentations -- and share your site with just a few people, your entire organization, or the world," gushes the official announcement at sites.google.com.

But industry blogger Zoli Erdos isn't impressed with Google's makeover of its JotSpot acquisition. "Google now has a pretty good and easy web-page creator with some wiki features made user-friendly, and a half-hearted attempt at integrating the rest of the Apps empire using Sites," he writes, adding: "Perhaps they get it right in the next release."

Dennis Howlett quibbles with the use of AJAX to allow users to add gadgets, which he finds sorely wanting. "At the very least, Google should get rid of the gadgets addition facility and rework it," he advises. "Otherwise, I sense the SMBs at which it is aimed will find the service a turn off."

Or, as he puts it very bluntly: "Please avoid the gadgets. They’ll drive you nuts."

Howlett goes to far as to say he believes Google is in danger of blowing its chance to out-Microsoft Microsoft and make SharePoint second-best:

"Google has a real chance to differentiate itself from Microsoft - which is clearly what it wants to do, while adding significant numbers of users to its Google Apps offering. It won’t do it this way because despite all the gripes around Microsoft products, the fact is Microsoft offers a more polished experience. Until Google truly understands this, it will find it difficult to adequately compete. In the meantime, offerings like Wetpaint and Ning have little to fear. They may not have the richness of other applications upon which to draw but given the usability issues I found, richness won’t be enough to push users over to Google."
For its part, Google remains confident, stating:
"Google Sites is the easiest way to make information accessible to people who need quick, up-to-date access. People can work together on a Site to add file attachments, information from other Google applications (like Google Docs, Google Calendar, YouTube and Picasa), and new free-form content."
Google Sites, the company points out, is integrated with other Google products, so you can insert videos, docs, spreadsheets, presentations, photo slide shows, and calendars directly onto your Google Sites pages.

SYS-CON.com readers can and will doubtless judge for themselves: http://sites.google.com/index.html.


Last Chance to Register for AJAXWorld 2008 East and Save $100 !


AJAXWorld 2008 West Call for Papers Is Open!

Submissions deadline: May 31, 2008

Next October's Conference is already receiving higher-caliber submissions from all over the Rich Internet Applications ecosphere.

The theme of this October's AJAXWorld Conference & Expo 2008 West is 'Beyond AJAX to the RIA Era' and the Call for Papers, which is now open, specifically encourages submissions from exceptional speakers with high-quality use cases of the fast-emerging RIA alternatives.

Submissions featuring such use cases as well as on dozens of other RIA topics have already begun streaming in to AJAXWorld Conference & Expo 2008 West, being held in San Jose, CA, on October 20-22, 2008.

Click here to submit your speaking proposal today !

More Stories By RIA News Desk

Ever since Google popularized a smarter, more responsive and interactive Web experience by using AJAX (Asynchronous JavaScript + XML) for its Google Maps & Gmail applications, SYS-CON's RIA News Desk has been covering every aspect of Rich Internet Applications and those creating and deploying them. If you have breaking RIA news, please send it to RIA@sys-con.com to share your product and company news coverage with AJAXWorld readers.

Comments (1) View Comments

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


Most Recent Comments
Werner Keil 03/01/08 09:38:06 AM EST

I can't help it, but talking about comparisons between Google and Microsoft, most of these sites make the impression of a cross over between Microsoft Works and Microsoft Bob, probably one of their biggest failures...