Welcome!

Java Authors: Liz McMillan, Walter H. Pinson, III, Maureen O'Gara, Yakov Werde, Tony Bishop

Related Topics: SOA & WOA, Oracle

SOA & WOA: Article

Managing Complexity Within a BPEL Environment

Using the right tools and methodology

BPEL Runtime Governance and Suitcase Deployment
As an administrator, you are responsible for deploying BPEL processes to a single server or multiple servers. Think about transitioning a BPEL process from test to production or deploying the process to additional BPEL engines to add scalability and availability to your system.

Typically BPEL processes are packaged in an archive known as a BPEL suitcase, which contains a .bpel file, WSDL for partner links, and classes and schemas required by the BPEL process. If you are using an SCA-compliant composite application, it may contain a BPEL module. As an administrator, you may be deploying the BPEL suitcase to more than one BPEL engine. You may want to deploy BPEL processes during off-peak times, so you want to automate the deployment procedure.

To automate deployment of BPEL processes, you can build scripts by using tools provided by your BPEL server vendors. If you're using a management tool, it may provide support for uploading the BPEL suitcases to the software library and then enable you to deploy them as needed. Figure 2 outlines the deployment of BPEL suitcases from a software library.

If your BPEL processes depend on resources such as adapters, it makes sense for you to automate the deployment and configuration of them if you want to avoid any manual errors.

Manage Versioning of BPEL Processes
In a dynamic environment, BPEL processes may change, depending on business needs. You need to implement a method of storing different versions of BPEL that have previously been deployed to the BPEL engine. This will help you track changes between different versions and back track any changes, should you run into issues. You may need to compare different versions of processes within one BPEL server or across BPEL servers. Management tools may provide the ability to store/retrieve and compare versions of a process and dependent artifacts such as WSDL and XML Schema that helps in the quick resolution of issues. The software library will allow you to roll back to a previous version of the BPEL process, should the need arise.

Monitor BPEL Process and Partner Links
Monitoring the health of BPEL processes is critical to meeting service-level agreements for your processes. You can probably ensure availability and meet service-level requirements by ensuring performance and functioning of the partner links your BPEL processes depend on and identifying problems in a proactive manner. You can develop some SOAP tests to verify the availability and performance of partner links. Use either a SOAP testing tool provided by a vendor or an open source Web service testing tool such as soapUI (http://soapUI.org). The correct approach is to automate tests to be performed at regular intervals. You want to be alerted when a particular partner link has an unscheduled service shutdown or a longer-than-expected response time. If you're using a management tool to manage your BPEL infrastructure, check whether it provides such a capability.

SOAP Test Example
The Elevation Query Web Service returns the elevation in feet or meters for a specific latitude/longitude (WGS 1984) point from the USGS Seamless Elevation datasets hosted at http://eros.usgs.gov.

WSDL

Operation
getElevation
Input Parameter X: 45.890610
Input Parameter Y: 7.157390
other parameters: left empty
Output Parameter: elevation of latitude/longitude provided.

You can monitor this Web Service by executing a SOAP test at regular intervals through automated tests. These SOAP tests monitor the availability and perceived performance of the Web service. Figure 3 depicts automating testing of Web services.

Monitoring BPEL Processes from the End-User Perspective
Your BPEL process may be accessed from different locations, and you want to monitor the availability and performance from those locations. Say you're part of a global organization and users in North America, Europe, and Asia access your BPEL processes. Although it's challenging to monitor the performance of BPEL processes from the end-user perspective, you can create an agent at the customer locations to test the performance from their end. However, manually performing these types of tasks from a BPEL process that is accessed from multiple customer sites could be challenging. Hence, you can use the help of management tools to monitor the performance of your BPEL applications from the end-user perspective as depicted in Figure 3.

Error/Fault Monitoring
A BPEL process may raise errors and faults for several reasons, including data exceptions or non-availability of partner links, although you need to limit the number of faults in BPEL processes by proactively monitoring the processes, as we described earlier. You need to drill down into the processes that have raised faults, and you should be able to diagnose the cause of the faults and make sure that this does not happen again. You may want to monitor the processes that failed and help diagnose issues by using tools provided by your BPEL vendor and take corrective action as appropriate. It will also help if you implement some methodology to monitor SOAP messages sent to and received by the BPEL process and the partner links.

Gateway to BPEL Engines
BPEL process instances are created when invoked by a client and the traffic is routed through Web servers and load balancers. You want to be alerted when these Web servers or load balancers are not available or not meeting the expected performance goals.

Managing the BPEL Engine
The BPEL engine is by far the most important part of the BPEL ecosystem. You have to monitor the availability and performance of BPEL engines and need to be alerted when a BPEL engine is not performing as expected. You may have multiple instances of clustered BPEL engines. Hence, you need to know if any one of the engines is not performing or whether the load balancer is working properly. More important, you want to find out proactively when all the engines are not performing because it will lead to total disruption of service.

Configuration Management and Versioning
You may change the configuration of your BPEL engines from time to time. You may want to track any interim changes and to backtrack changes to a previous version. If you follow ITIL practices, this should sound familiar. You can store the configuration of a BPEL engine in a configuration management database (CMDB) or version control system. It can make your life easier to have your management tool provide integration with the CMDB in which you store your configuration.

Keeping a gold image of your BPEL ecosystem configuration and using it to compare with your current configuration will help in identifying issues attributable to configuration changes. And keeping track of components added to and/or removed from your BPEL system will also help in analyzing performance issues - for example, performance was bad during the first week of January but improved afterward, because there was one extra BPEL engine in the cluster after the first week of January. By comparing the current configuration with the gold image, you can monitor changes in some parameters that can have a big impact on BPEL instance throughput, such as dispatcher thread min/max parameters.

More Stories By Debu Panda

Debu Panda, lead author of the recently published EJB 3 in Action (Manning Publications), is a senior principal product manager on the Oracle Application Server development team, where he drives development of the Java EE container. He has more than 15 years of experience in the IT industry and has published numerous articles on enterprise Java technologies and has presented at many conferences. Debu maintains an active blog on enterprise Java at http://www.debupanda.com.

More Stories By Arvind Maheshwari

Arvind Maheshwari, a senior software development manager for the Oracle Enterprise Manager development team, is focused on building management solutions for middleware. He has 14 years of experience in the IT industry and has played the role of developer, consultant, architect, and manager in the financial, manufacturing, and telecom industries, developing enterprise solutions that are deployed in high-availability architectures.

Comments (0)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.