Three RIA Tools Examined: JSF, Flex, and JavaFX @ JAVA DEVELOPER'S JOURNAL

Three RIA Tools Examined: JSF, Flex, and JavaFX

2008 is going to be an important year for Rich Internet Applications

Apr. 18, 2008 04:00 PM

Digg This!

2008 is going to be an important year for Rich Internet Applications. Most organizations are delivering or planning to deliver Rich Internet Applications; however, at the same time, most IT managers are facing a dilemma: which Rich Internet Application technology and platform to use? The number of different frameworks and libraries is too vast to even consider evaluating a fraction of them.

To make this task manageable, I'm going to narrow things down to three different technologies for delivering enterprise-level Rich Internet Applications. While the first two (JSF and Flex) are proven technologies that have been used for a numbers of years, JavaFX is a new declarative language for building rich user interfaces using Java.

Page 1 of 3 next page »

Published Apr. 18, 2008 — Reads 34,295
Copyright © 2008 SYS-CON Media. All Rights Reserved.

▪ The Business Case for Rich Internet Applications

▪ Rich Internet Applications vs AJAX: "2008 Will Be A Crucial Year"

▪ Moving Beyond AJAX: 2008 Is the Decision Year For RIAs

▪ Bringing RIAs into the Enterprise: New Challenges, New Solutions

▪ Rich Internet Applications: 2008 is the Year the RIA Category Accelerates

▪ Rich Semantic Internet Applications with Flex

▪ AJAXWorld Keynote Speaker on the Risks and Rewards of RIAs

▪ The Business Value of RIAs: An Informal, Virtual Round Table

▪ Model-View-Controller and the Brave New World of Rich Internet Applications

▪ Rich Internet Applications: Tips, Tricks & Techniques

▪ Choose Your Rich Internet Applications Trajectory at AJAXWorld in New York City

▪ Next-Generation RIAs: Future Directions for Rich Internet Applications

About Max Katz
Max Katz is a senior systems engineer at Exadel. He has been helping customers jump-start their RIA development as well as providing mentoring, consulting, and training. Max is a recognized subject-matter expert in the JSF developer community. He has provided JSF/RichFaces training for the past three years, presented at many conferences, and written several published articles on JSF-related topics. Max also leads Exadel's RIA strategy and writes about RIA technologies in his blog, http://mkblog.exadel.com. Max holds a BS in computer science from the University of California, Davis.

Tom Van den Eynde wrote: It's simple: go with Adobe Flex - it simply rocks.

read & respond »

DW wrote: Hmmm, have you checked out the Orbeon Fo rms?(http://www.orbeon.co m/)

read & respond »

Hmmm wrote: Yes, XForms sounds good. PicoForms offers a solution that would work, and Yahoo has done their new mobile back end using server-side tech. An on-device XForms processor would help write portable mobile apps.

read & respond »

skalvi wrote: If I want to write an enterprise application for my business and I want my PC user's to be able to use it as well as mobile user's, java will not work. Web start will work on the PC but not a PDA, since I would have to use a midilet. Same with flash. I would have to develop in flash lite for the PDA's. I would have to write different version of the same program for different devices. The same with GWT for the PC based version. I would have to write a seperate application for Android and the Davlik jvm. This is where JSF is most suitable, with the concept of plugable rendering kits. Why can't I just use GWT on the gphone? Maybe I can. Maybe we should hybridize JSF. So what is the best platform for write one run anywhere? anyone?

read & respond »

Confusion Solution wrote: > The number of different frameworks and libraries > is too vast to even consider evaluating a fraction of > them So just use Flex instead, hehe!

read & respond »

Max wrote: @Michael: Nowhere am I comparing JSF and Flex, I'm merely discussing various technologies and delivery platforms for RIA applications. Nowhere am I saying that one is better than the other. I'm not sure why you would want to hand-code JavaScript, unless you are building a framework, doing a school project or some research. Do you consider GWT (Google Web Toolkit) to be a good Ajax framework? They do exactly the same, they hide the JavaScript from you.

read & respond »

Michael wrote: sorry, but comparing JSF and Flex is ridiculous. JSF has nothing to do with RIA. You might say that JSF is a possibility to build Ajax apps, but then: why JSF? It is utterly unsuited for Ajax compared to other web frameworks BECAUSE it hides the JS from the dev.

read & respond »

Alex wrote: Good article. It misses one important comment though. Your JSF example has to make a server call to the pojo to increment the click counter, while both Flex and JavaFX example do not need to do this because of their stateful nature, which is very important. Out of these three, Flash Player's UI looks better than others.

read & respond »

DW wrote: What about XHTML and XForms Offline?

read & respond »

LATEST JAVA STORIES & POSTS

Sun Challenges Linux

By Maureen O'Gara

Sun's mule train has finally pulled into Indiana after three years on the road. Indiana is the Linux-friendly Fedora-like OpenSolaris project meant to move the Solaris-shy Linux community off Linux and on to Solaris tempted by Solaris widgetry like the highly scalable, rollback-e

AJAX World - Sun Talks Up its Late-to-the-Party AIR-Silverlight Rival

By Maureen O'Gara

At Java One this week Sun has been selling its year -old-but-still-upcoming - and definitely late-to-the-party - Adobe AIR- and Microsoft Silverlight-competitive JavaFX Rich Client environment as a potential revenue-generator capable of putting ads on mobile applications and JavaF

JavaOne Archives - Dvorak Comments on AMD Intel Lawsuit on SYS-CON.TV

By Virtualization News Desk

Conference in San Francisco. Dvorak held forth on a number of topics, including the new AMD/Intel lawsuit, the viability of Java and Sun, the value of (or lack thereof) of corporate PR, and whether or not a new book about Silicon Valley is really worth reading.

Microsoft To Keynote 4th International Virtualization Conference & Expo

By Virtualization News Desk

Mike Neil is general manager for virtualization strategy in the Windows Server Division at Microsoft. Mike is focused on the delivery of the Windows virtualization technology, including Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V, Microsoft Hyper-V Server and Virtual PC 2007. Mike also directs t

Borland Finally Dumps CodeGear Tools Division

By Maureen O'Gara

It's only taken Borland two years but it's finally dumped its CodeGear tools division, responsible for Borland's hereditary JBuilder, Delphi and C++ Builder lines as well as its new web ventures into PHP and Ruby, said to be used by 7.5 million developers. Embarcadero Technologie

Sun Adds Comprehensive Video Capabilities to Java Platform With On2 Technologies

By Java News Desk

Sun Microsystems announced it has entered into a multi-year agreement with On2 Technologies to add comprehensive video capabilities, using On2 Technologies TrueMotion video codecs, to Sun's JavaFX, a family of products for creating Rich Internet Applications (RIAs) with immersive